Scoops & Cones: The Best Ice Cream Shops Near Maine-Endwell, NY

Maine-Endwell sits at the heart of the Greater Binghamton area, putting it within easy reach of a surprisingly rich ice cream scene, from longtime local institutions to hidden gems.

Here's a guide to the best spots within 20 miles.

1. Sammy's Ice Cream and Italian Ice: 3208 E. Main Street, Endwell, NY. Hours: Daily, 2:00 PM – 9:00 PM. (607) 658-6732 | Drive-through available | Facebook: SammysIce

Your closest option and a great one, Sammy's is right on E. Main Street in Endwell and offers both soft-serve ice cream and Italian ice, plus a drive-through window for maximum convenience. Reviewers rave about the rich, creamy soft-serve (described as among the best in the area), and the shop also does creative cake pops served in adorable mini cones, making it a popular party destination. Cookie crumble and fruity pebbles milkshakes are customer favorites.

2. Wolfie's Ice Cream: 2305 Country Club Road, Endwell, NY. Hours: Mon–Sat 12:00 PM – 9:00 PM | Sun 1:00 PM – 9:00 PM. (607) 239-6788

A beloved neighborhood staple open for over 20 years, Wolfie's serves Hershey's ice cream and has cultivated a fiercely loyal local following. One reviewer described their young son spotting the familiar sign from the car and shouting "Teddy Bear Ice Cream!" in pure excitement — that kind of multigenerational loyalty says it all. Clean, friendly, plenty of seating, and open all year long.

3. Classics Ice Cream Parlor: 1001 Union Center Maine Highway, Endicott, NY. Hours: Daily, 4:00 PM – 7:00 PM. (607) 766-8257

A perfect five-star rating and a truly unique atmosphere — Classics is decked out with vintage ice cream parlor decor, beautiful murals, classic tables and chairs, and a Frank Sinatra soundtrack playing in the background. It serves Hershey's ice cream, and the milkshakes (especially pistachio) are standouts. Note the early closing time of 7:00 PM — don't leave it too late in the evening.

4. Lickity Split Ice Cream Shoppe: 152 Vestal Parkway E, Vestal, NY. Hours: Mon–Fri 3:00 PM – 9:00 PM | Sat 1:00 PM – 9:00 PM | Sun 1:00 PM – 8:00 PM. (607) 754-2222

A local favorite on the Vestal Parkway with a nice variety of homemade ice cream flavors, generous portions, and attentive staff who are happy to let you sample before you commit. The brownie ice cream sandwich is a must-try specialty. There's indoor seating, making it a good rainy-day option, and the staff regularly earns praise for their warmth and patience.

5. Funky Beez: 1344 State Route 26, Vestal, NY. Hours: Daily, 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM. (607) 205-1426

One of the most well-rounded family destinations in the area, Funky Beez pairs a massive selection of hard and soft-serve flavors (including cannoli soft-serve and non-dairy options) with gourmet hot dogs, slushies, sundaes, and shakes. The real bonus: a fenced playground for kids, plenty of outdoor seating, clean restrooms, and both cash and card accepted. Opens early at 11 AM — great for a lunchtime treat or afternoon outing.

6. Tastie Cream Inc: 2021 Vestal Parkway W, Vestal, NY. Hours: Daily, 2:00 PM – 9:00 PM. (607) 484-0406

A favorite for fans of old-fashioned homemade custard and Italian ice, Tastie Cream is known for rich, dense flavors — blueberry cheesecake, maple walnut, and black raspberry are perennial crowd-pleasers. Portions are generous, and the staff is friendly. Best of all, it's located near a miniature golf course, making it a natural double stop for a summer evening out.

7. Sugar Lips Ice Cream Shop: 103 Riverside Drive, Johnson City, NY. Hours: Daily, 12:00 PM – 10:00 PM. (607) 321-3334. Cash only

A hip and creative shop that specializes in homemade seasonal flavors with names like "Cereal Killer," "Fall in Vermont," and "Party Animal." Sugar Lips also offers ice cream flights — perfect for the indecisive — along with fun, quirky seating, including ice cream cone chairs. Open until 10 PM, it's one of the later options in the area. Bring cash, as cards aren't accepted.

8. Scoopy Dooby's Ice Cream: 45 Lewis Street, Binghamton, NY. Hours: Mon–Thu 5:00–9:00 PM | Fri 5:00–10:00 PM | Sat 3:00–10:00 PM | Sun 3:00–9:00 PM

A convenient neighborhood ice cream shop with a solid selection of flavors and notably good milkshakes. It opens in the late afternoon/evening, making it ideal for an after-dinner dessert run. Some reviewers have noted inconsistent closing times, so arriving with a few minutes to spare is advisable.

9. Frosty Joe's: 1 Track Drive, Binghamton, NY. Hours: Daily, 11:30 AM – 9:00 PM. (607) 760-9633

One of the highest-rated shops in the entire region, Frosty Joe's is a standout for its 24 flavors of soft-serve with a wide variety of flavored dips, plus a great selection of hard scoop flavors, including ube, peach, and blueberry pancake. It's also one of the most inclusive shops around, with dedicated vegan and gluten-free options. Live entertainment adds to the fun atmosphere on select nights. Generous portions, reasonable prices, and plenty of outdoor seating.

10. Suzy-Q's: 1110 Chenango Street, Binghamton, NY. Hours: Daily, 12:00 PM – 9:30 PM. (607) 723-3206

A family-owned gem with deep community roots — the walls are lined with photos of regulars going back years. Suzy-Q's is widely considered to have the best soft-serve in the area, and also offers hard ice cream, ice cream cakes, and a full food menu, including burgers. The staff is consistently praised for their kindness (they once held onto a customer's dropped $25 until they called back). Open until 9:30 PM, one of the later closing times around.

11. Jones Humdinger: 1441 Front Street, Binghamton, NY. Hours: Mon–Thu & Sun 12:00–8:00 PM | Fri–Sat 12:00–9:00 PM. (607) 771-6501 | Cash only (ATM on site) | joneshumdinger.com

A true Binghamton institution that makes its own ice cream in-house rather than serving a standard commercial brand. The portions here are famously massive — first-timers are strongly advised to order a size smaller than they think they need. Standout flavors include Boston Cream, chocolate ecstasy with peanut butter sauce, and a beloved black raspberry soft-serve swirl. Cash only, but there's an ATM outside.

12. Ice Cream Works!: 14 George Street, Owego, NY. Hours: Daily, 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM. (607) 687-2253

Worth the short drive to the charming village of Owego, Ice Cream Works! offers an impressive mix of homemade flavors alongside Perry's (a beloved upstate NY brand), plus a full sub menu using Boar's Head meats. Creative house flavors like "NY Potholes" (chocolate with dark chocolate chunks) and "Right Turn, Clyde" (banana with chocolate chips) set it apart from a standard ice cream stand. A great stop if you're exploring the Tioga County area.

13. The Scoop of Whitney Point: Route 11, Whitney Point, NY. Hours: Daily, 12:00 PM – 9:00 PM. (607) 692-3957

A family-owned and operated community hub with a wonderfully laid-back vibe — kids playing in the grass, neighbors chatting, and generous scoops at very wallet-friendly prices. Offers both hard and soft-serve with some creative flavor combinations you won't find elsewhere, like peanut butter cookie dough caramel, and mint ting-a-ling. A group of four people has reportedly left with full cones for under $16.

Hours and seasonal availability may vary. Always a good idea to call ahead or check social media, especially early or late in the season. Know of a spot we missed? Let us know!